Hand holding a gavel with scales of justice on a vibrant purple background, symbolizing legal action and balance.

Congress Targets Forced Arbitration and Deepfake Abuse as Roblox Faces Mounting Scrutiny

Congress is moving to curb forced arbitration in Roblox cases and let deepfake victims sue creators, with time running out in 2026.

Updated November 18, 2026 10:26 pm

In short

Congress is moving on two fronts to expand victims’ legal options: ending forced arbitration in certain online-harm cases, and creating a direct lawsuit path for victims of nonconsensual intimate deepfakes.

  • Senate lawmakers targeted forced arbitration in online-harm cases, with Roblox at the center of the debate.
  • A Hawley-Durbin bill would make arbitration unenforceable in child sexual exploitation and child cyber-injury disputes.
  • The Defiance Act would let victims sue creators of nonconsensual intimate deepfakes.
  • Paris Hilton backed the deepfake bill on Capitol Hill and said she has more than 100,000 AI-generated explicit images and videos made of her.
  • Congress has only a few weeks left in its 2026 session, raising the odds that any deal must ride on a year-end bill.

Update — November 18, 2026 10:26 pm

Lawmakers also unveiled a second, related arbitration bill from Sens. Richard Blumenthal, Katie Britt and Cory Booker. Unlike the Hawley-Durbin proposal, it would specifically add data-privacy violations to the list of disputes that could not be forced into private arbitration.

On the deepfake side, Paris Hilton said she would keep returning to Congress until the Defiance Act passes, and she repeated that she has been targeted by more than 100,000 explicit AI-generated images and videos. A separate advocate, Elliston Berry, also testified that a classmate used a deepfake to circulate a sexually explicit image of her friend group when she was 14.

U.S. lawmakers on Tuesday moved to make it easier for victims of online abuse to sue, putting Roblox’s arbitration practices and the Defiance Act for deepfake victims at the center of a fast-closing congressional window. The push could shift disputes over child safety and nonconsensual intimate images out of private arbitration and into open court, where plaintiffs and regulators can press claims publicly.

What lawmakers are trying to change

At a Senate Judiciary subcommittee hearing, lawmakers focused on forced arbitration in cases involving online harm, with Roblox’s child-grooming litigation serving as the immediate flashpoint. According to The Verge, the company has faced accusations that it uses arbitration clauses to block complaints from people who were minors when they signed up.

The central legislative proposal in that hearing was a bill from Sens. Josh Hawley and Dick Durbin. The measure would make arbitration clauses unenforceable in disputes involving child sexual exploitation and what the bill calls child cyber injury. The scope is broad: The Verge reported that it would cover reputational harm, mental suffering and death tied to alleged child cyber injury.

Why the Roblox fight matters

Roblox has become a proxy battle over whether companies that host large youth audiences can funnel serious safety disputes away from judges and juries. The Verge said the company is facing about 180 lawsuits in consolidated litigation over alleged failures to protect children. That scale matters because it gives the hearing real-world weight: lawmakers are not debating a theoretical loophole, but a live dispute with hundreds of pending claims.

Forced arbitration typically sends disputes to private proceedings rather than public courts. Supporters of the practice say it can be faster and less costly. Critics argue it can silence victims, especially children and families who may not understand what they agreed to when they opened an account years earlier.

Roblox’s public-policy chief, Nicky Jackson Colaço, pushed back on the idea that arbitration language says much about safety. “A legal position about arbitration is not a measure of a company’s safety record,” she said, according to The Verge.

How is the deepfake bill different?

The second major push on Capitol Hill is the Defiance Act, a proposal aimed at giving victims of nonconsensual intimate deepfakes the right to sue the people who create them. Deepfakes are AI-generated fake images or videos, often used for sexualized impersonation, and lawmakers have increasingly treated them as a distinct harm rather than a niche internet abuse problem.

Paris Hilton appeared on Capitol Hill to back the bill, joining representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Laurel Lee at an advocacy event. Hilton has become one of the most visible public faces of the campaign against sexually explicit deepfakes. She told lawmakers she has more than 100,000 AI-generated explicit images and videos made of her, and said more than 50 million people have been victimized by sexually explicit deepfakes.

“But when I make a promise to survivors, I keep it.”

That line, attributed to Hilton by The Verge, captures the broader pitch behind the bill: that victims should not be left with only platform complaints or takedown requests when the harm is deliberate, intimate and widely distributed.

What the Defiance Act would do

The fact sheet says the bill would let victims sue creators of nonconsensual intimate images. That is a meaningful shift in legal strategy. Instead of forcing victims to rely solely on site moderation, platform reporting tools or criminal complaints that may not fit every case, the legislation would open a direct civil route against alleged creators.

The bill also speaks to a larger policy problem. The Verge noted that Section 230 has long shielded online platforms from some liability, though it does not cover all claims. That has left victims, lawmakers and advocates looking for ways to target the people who make the content or the systems that help distribute it.

Why it matters

These bills are about more than one company or one celebrity case. They point to a broader effort in Washington to redraw the boundaries between private online rules and public law. If lawmakers succeed, victims of sexual exploitation, child cyber injury and deepfake abuse could have more leverage to bring their complaints into court.

For families, that could mean a clearer path to accountability when a child is harmed on a platform that used an arbitration clause to channel the case elsewhere. For creators and hosts of synthetic media, it could mean greater exposure to civil claims if they produce or circulate sexualized deepfakes. For platforms, the risk is obvious: rules that once limited litigation could be narrowed, and companies could face more public scrutiny in court filings and trials.

There is also a political timing issue. Congress has only a few weeks left in its 2026 session before a new Democratic majority is expected to be sworn in January. That makes the current stretch unusually important. Lawmakers may try to attach broader policy items to year-end bills such as the NDAA, the annual defense package that often becomes a vehicle for unrelated legislation.

In practical terms, that means the fate of these proposals may depend less on standalone momentum and more on whether they can be folded into a must-pass measure before the calendar runs out.

Background: how Congress got here

Forced arbitration has long been a flashpoint in consumer and employment law. The basic idea is simple: a contract can require disputes to be decided privately rather than in open court. In online settings, those agreements often appear in terms of service that users accept quickly, sometimes before they are old enough to understand the consequences.

That dynamic has created tension in child-safety cases. The Verge reported that Roblox has been accused of using arbitration to block complaints from users who were minors when they signed up. If true, that would mean a child or parent could be forced into a private forum years after the account was created, even when the underlying allegations involve grooming or exploitation.

The hearing also showed how lawmakers are connecting online product design to real-world harm. Myriam Gilles, a Northwestern University law professor, said she “never expected to come before this body to talk about its use against 9 year olds.” Her testimony, as described by The Verge, underscores why the issue resonates politically: arbitration is no longer being debated only in the abstract, but as a tool that can shape outcomes in cases involving very young children.

Roblox, for its part, has said in the public-policy statement quoted by The Verge that arbitration should not be read as a proxy for safety. That distinction matters because the company is not only defending a contract clause; it is trying to prevent that clause from becoming shorthand for its broader child-protection record.

By the numbers

Several figures from the hearing and the broader debate help explain why lawmakers are treating the issue as urgent.

Figure What it refers to Why it matters
About 180 lawsuits Roblox cases in consolidated litigation over alleged child safety failures Shows the scale of legal exposure already surrounding the platform
100,000+ images and videos AI-generated explicit depictions of Paris Hilton that she says were created Illustrates the volume of harm victims say deepfake tools can cause
50 million+ people Hilton’s estimate of victims of sexually explicit deepfakes Suggests the issue has moved far beyond isolated abuse cases
Under 16 Roblox’s age-based account default described by the company Highlights why child-user protections are central to the debate
9 year olds Example age cited in testimony about forced arbitration use against minors Shows how young some affected users can be when account terms are imposed
3+ weeks Time left in Congress’s 2026 session Explains the narrow legislative window before the political shift in January

What lawmakers said on Capitol Hill

Josh Hawley framed the issue as a matter of access to justice. “The best thing we can do in terms of enforcement is we can open up the courthouse doors,” he said, according to The Verge. That language reflects the basic political argument behind the bill: if claims are serious enough, they should be heard publicly rather than hidden inside a private process.

The hearing’s focus on Roblox also gave lawmakers a concrete example to cite when discussing how arbitration can work in online-harm disputes. The alleged harms range from exploitation to reputational damage and mental suffering, and the proposed bill would explicitly sweep those injuries into its coverage.

Another arbitration bill, backed by Sens. Richard Blumenthal, Katie Britt and Cory Booker, would go further by also covering data privacy violations. That suggests there is broader bipartisan interest in rethinking arbitration, even if the specific bills differ in scope and political support.

What happens next

The immediate question is whether any of the proposals can move before Congress adjourns. The Verge reported that lawmakers have only a few weeks left in the 2026 session, and that the calendar could push them toward year-end vehicles rather than separate votes.

Here are the main things to watch:

  • Whether the Hawley-Durbin arbitration bill advances in the Senate before adjournment.
  • Whether the Defiance Act gains enough support to move in the lame-duck session.
  • Whether lawmakers try to attach either proposal to the NDAA or another must-pass bill.
  • How Roblox responds if Congress narrows the enforceability of its arbitration clauses.
  • Whether the broader push against deepfake abuse turns into a larger legislative package next year.

Timing will matter as much as substance. A new Democratic majority is expected in January, which means the next few weeks may be the last realistic chance for the current Congress to shape the issue on its own terms. If these bills stall, advocates may have to wait for a new political setup to revisit them. If they advance, the fight over online harm could move one step closer to a legal framework that gives victims more room to sue in public.

Context: why this is becoming a larger tech policy fight

The legislative push reflects a broader pattern in tech policy: lawmakers are increasingly trying to match digital harms with legal remedies that were built for the offline world. Child exploitation, reputational injury and sexual impersonation do not fit neatly into older assumptions about contracts, moderation and liability.

Section 230 still shapes that debate by limiting some platform liability, but it does not resolve the question of who should be accountable when harmful content is created, shared or facilitated. That gap is part of why Congress is considering separate pathways for arbitration reform and deepfake litigation rather than one sweeping bill.

It also helps explain why a gaming platform and a celebrity-backed anti-deepfake campaign are now appearing in the same policy conversation. Both involve the same underlying problem: when online harm is serious, fast and personal, victims often want a route to court that does not vanish into private dispute resolution or platform bureaucracy.

For now, the answer from Capitol Hill is not yet final. But Tuesday’s hearing and advocacy push showed that lawmakers are actively testing whether the law can keep pace with the kinds of damage users say they are already suffering.

Frequently asked questions

What is Congress trying to do about forced arbitration in online-harm cases?

Congress is trying to make forced arbitration harder to use in serious online-harm disputes, especially cases involving child sexual exploitation and child cyber injury. The Hawley-Durbin bill would make those arbitration clauses unenforceable, so victims could bring claims in court instead of private proceedings.

Why is Roblox part of the arbitration debate?

Roblox is part of the debate because The Verge reported that lawmakers are examining whether the company uses arbitration clauses to block complaints from users who were minors when they signed up. The company is also facing about 180 lawsuits in consolidated litigation over alleged child safety failures.

What would the Defiance Act do?

The Defiance Act would let victims of nonconsensual intimate deepfakes sue the creators of those images or videos. That would give victims a direct civil route to court, rather than relying only on takedowns, platform reporting or criminal complaints that may not fully address the harm.

Why did Paris Hilton appear on Capitol Hill?

Paris Hilton appeared on Capitol Hill to support the Defiance Act and push for stronger remedies against sexually explicit deepfakes. The Verge reported that she joined Representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Laurel Lee for an advocacy event in support of the bill.

Will these bills pass before Congress adjourns?

It is uncertain whether either bill will pass before Congress adjourns. The Verge reported that lawmakers have only a few weeks left in the 2026 session, and any proposal may need to move as part of a larger year-end bill such as the NDAA.

Share this 🚀